|
At least one in three Americans will develop some type of
cancer in their lifetime.[i] Nutrition and physical activity play a
tremendous role in cancer prevention. As
many as one third of all U.S. cancer deaths could be prevented through diet and
exercise.[ii] Being overweight or obese is a risk factor
for at least seven types of cancer.[iii] The National Institute
of Health asserts that
obesity prevention efforts must begin during childhood. A diet with few nutrient-rich foods, a lack
of
physical activity, and tobacco use all increase a person’s risk of
developing cancer. The Centers for
Disease Control (CDC)
has concluded that education can be more effective than
regulatory measures in long-term reduction of tobacco use.
However, only 5% of U.S. schools have
executed the CDC’s smoking prevention recommendations.[iv]
There are
countless programs that target conditions that lead to chronic illnesses but
very little work has been done
in cancer prevention education. According to Slawta J., et. al, health
promotion programs for children are successful and
may favorably alter obesity
and the development of lifestyle-related diseases in adulthood. A study discussing children’s
knowledge and attitudes
towards cigarette smoking and its damage illustrated that the students
lacked knowledge with regard to the dangers of tobacco use, and it recommended
that the topic should be incorporated in
teacher’s lesson plans.[v] The study also noted that physicians, nurses
and educational advisors suggested that health
education should be implemented
beginning in first and second grade.
Thus,
effective health education is a sound investment in the future. According to the USDA, healthy diet could prevent
at least $71 billion per year in
medical costs, lost productivity, and lost lives.[vi] Tobacco use causes 440,000 deaths
annually and costs $75 billion just in direct medical costs.[vii] Keeping one child from smoking will save $230
per year in
medical expenses throughout his life.[viii] Preventing one child from becoming obese will
save her $395 per year.[ix]
If Road of Life’s program saves just one
child from dying of cancer, the value to society is estimated to be between
$5.5 million
and $7.5 million.[x] These figures show the high value of a modest
investment in health education.
In
light of this information, Road of Life
is the only organization in the U.S. working exclusively on cancer prevention
for
children. Road of Life currently
works with schools, hospitals, and youth-serving nonprofit organizations to
help them incorporate
health education with an emphasis on cancer prevention
into their existing programs. The health education curriculum emphasizes
nutrition, physical activity and the dangers of tobacco use and is aligned with
the State Academic Standards as well as the
National Health Education
Standards. It is Road of Life’s mission to eradicate preventable cancers and
diseases of excess by
educating children about the smoking, fitness, and nutrition
decisions they can make to lead healthier lives.
Road of Life Pilot Intervention Summary
Objective: To analyze the impact of Road of Life’s classroom curriculum
education program on the knowledge, beliefs, and
behaviors associated with
nutrition, physical activity, and tobacco use. In 2007, Road of Life released the classroom
curriculum
as well as the after-school curriculum that focuses on general
health, nutrition, physical activity, and tobacco use awareness.
To provide a greater understanding of the
effects of our programs and health initiatives, Road of Life designed and
conducted
an evaluation to capture the impact of our health education
curriculum. Listed below is a brief
summary of the initial evaluation
outcomes of the Road of Life intervention
study.
Classroom Curriculum
Design: The students in the
intervention group were given a 70 question pre-test survey before
any Road of
Life curriculum instruction. This
pre-test helped educators determine the participants’ current knowledge about
nutrition, physical activity, and the dangers of tobacco use. After learning the curriculum, the post-test
was administered 6
months later to monitor the positive changes in students’
knowledge, beliefs and behaviors about nutrition, physical activity, and
tobacco use. The 70 questions are
specific to the Road of Life curricula and were designed to demonstrate the
knowledge and
beliefs that the children learned concerning general health,
nutrition, physical activity, and tobacco use awareness. The behavioral
questions are questions
designed to analyze proper nutritional intake, physical activity, and tobacco
use.
Subjects: The students in the intervention group were
from a rural/small town with moderate to median family incomes, as
determined by the categories designated by the Ohio Department of
Education. The participants
were 69 girls and 66 boys,
elementary school-aged and in the third and fourth
grades. Of the 135 student participants
97% were white and the remaining
3% were other, American Indian or Alaska
Native.
Results: Statistical
significance was set at p <= .1 (90% confidence interval). Overall the sample showed a statistically
significant improvement in a range of questions from all three core areas:
knowledge, beliefs, and behavior. Over
51% of
both the knowledge and belief section questions demonstrated
statistically significant improvement in student responses
between the pre- and
post-test survey. In addition, 40 % of
the behavior section questions showed statistically significant
improvement in
student responses. In the knowledge and
beliefs sections students showed even greater statistically significant
improvement (p <=.05 or 95% confidence interval) on 37% of the questions
regarding nutrition, physical education, and tobacco
use curricula. Furthermore, 34% of the questions (in the
behavior section showed this greater statistically significant
improvement (p
<=.05) in the area of nutrition, physical education, and tobacco use (Table
1).
Further analysis revealed specific
significant improvements in the area of nutritional knowledge on questions
about caffeine
dehydration, food labels, and serving sizes. In addition, students showed an increased
knowledge in available locations to be
physically active, high-energy activities,
and stretching in the area of physical activity knowledge. Students also showed
statistically
significant increased knowledge of the dangers of tobacco on questions related
to the short term consequences of
smoking and various tobacco products. In respect to beliefs, specific nutrition
questions about healthier food options, the
importance of breakfast, and
appropriate fruit and vegetable intake showed statistically significant
improvements. The belief
questions
regarding the image of people who smoke and safety in physical activity also
showed statistically significant
improvements in student responses. The majority of the statistically significant
questions in the area of behavior were about
positive nutritional food changes
and an increase in physical activity (see Appendix for a listing of the
specific questions).
Conclusions and Implications: The effects of nutrition, physical education, and tobacco
use curricula were measured in
terms of knowledge, beliefs, and behaviors. The results of the difference between pre-
and post- tests revealed that students
showed a statistically significant
improvement in a range of questions on nutrition, physical activity, and
tobacco use from the
three core areas of knowledge, beliefs, and behavior.
School health programs can help
children and adolescents reach good health by providing them with the
knowledge, skills,
social support, and environmental reinforcement they need to
adopt long-term, healthy nutrition and physical fitness behaviors.
Road of Life’s strategy is shown to be
effective in promoting significant improvements in knowledge, beliefs, and
behavior
regarding nutrition, physical education, and tobacco use. The curriculum Road of Life provides is a
beneficial and essential
resource for schools lacking comprehensive health
programs.
Research indicates that the participants that learn healthy
habits during early adolescence have a better chance of maintaining
these
habits throughout adulthood. By
educating youth about the importance of healthy lifestyle choices in childhood,
the Road
of Life programs can help to reduce adult rates of cancer and diseases
of excess including diabetes and obesity in adulthood.
This initial pilot study shows that students
exposed to the Road of Life Classroom Curriculum 2.0 show statistically
significant
improvements in their knowledge, beliefs and behaviors relating to
nutrition, physical education, and tobacco use.
Table 1: The
Percentage and Number of Questions in Each of the Core Areas Demonstrating
Statistical Significance
|
N = 135 Participants
|
Improvement in Questions
with Statistical Significance of p <=.05
|
Improvement in Questions
with Statistical Significance of p <=.1
|
|
Knowledge Questions (21)
|
33.3% (7)
|
52.4% (11)
|
|
Belief Questions (14)
|
42.9% (6)
|
50.0% (7)
|
|
Behavior Questions (35)
|
34.3% (12)
|
40.0% (14)
|
Appendix: Below are
the questions that the students demonstrated statistically significant
(p<=.1 or 90% confidence interval)
improvement between the pre and post test
survey.
Knowledge Section : *Indicates p<=.05 (95% confidence
interval)
1. High-energy activities make your heart beat faster and help to reduce
stress
2. Caffeine, which is found in soda pops, dehydrates your body.
3. * Not stretching before working out can cause you to break your muscles.
4. * Chewing tobacco is much safer than smoking cigarettes and cigars.
5. * Some short term consequences of smoking include: yellowing of teeth and
trouble breathing.
6. High energy activities can be done in all seasons
7. * Both an empty field and the YMCA offer a chance to be physically
active.
8. TV commercials often express the opinions of the products manufacturer.
9. * Food labels tell us how many nutrients are in an entire box or package
of food.
10. * A serving size is the amount of food a person should eat at one time.
11. * One serving of a fruit or vegetable is the size of a baseball.
Belief Section: *Indicates p<=.05 (95% confidence interval)
1. * When eating out, it best to order fruit for dessert.
2. * People smoke to look cool, look older, to fit in with friends and to
seem tough or independent.
3. * People can be physically active in every community.
4. * All sugars should be avoided.
5. * Eating at least five fruits and vegetables a day will make me healthy.
6. There are negative consequences to skipping breakfast.
7.
* It is easier to develop
healthy habits as and adult rather than a kid.
Behavior Section: *Indicates p<=.05 (95% confidence interval)
1.
* Yesterday, did you eat
any vegetables? Vegetables are all cooked and uncooked vegetables; salads; and
boiled,
baked and mashed potatoes. Do not count French fries or chips.
No, I didn’t eat any
vegetables yesterday.
Yes, I ate vegetables 1 time yesterday.
Yes, I ate vegetables 2 times yesterday.
Yes, I ate vegetables 3 or more times yesterday.
2.
* Yesterday,
did you drink any punch, Kool-Aid®, sports drinks, or other fruit-flavored
drinks?
Do not
count 100% fruit juice.
No, I didn’t
drink any of these drinks yesterday.
Yes, I drank
one of these drinks 1 time yesterday.
Yes, I drank
one of these drinks 2
times yesterday.
Yes, I drank
one of these drinks 3 or
more times yesterday.
3.
* Yesterday, did you eat
sweet rolls, doughnuts, cookies, brownies, pies, or cake?
No, I didn’t eat any of
the foods listed above yesterday.
Yes, I ate one of these
foods 1 time yesterday.
Yes, I ate one of these
foods 2 times yesterday.
Yes, I ate one of these
foods 3 or more times yesterday.
4.
* Yesterday, did you have
a snack? A snack is food or drink that you eat or drink before, after, or
between meals.
No, I didn’t have any
snacks yesterday.
Yes, I had a snack 1 time yesterday.
Yes, I had a snack 2 times yesterday.
Yes, I had a snack 3 or more times yesterday.
5.
* Yesterday, how many
times did you eat food from any type of restaurant? (Restaurants include fast
food,
sit down restaurants, pizza places, and cafeterias.)
None 1 time 2 times 3 or more times
6.
* On how many of the past
7 days did you exercise or take part in physical activity that made your heart
beat fast
and made you breathe hard for at
least 20 minutes? (For example:
basketball, soccer, running or jogging, fast dancing,
swimming laps, tennis,
fast bicycling, or similar activities)
0 days 1 day 2 days 3 days 4 days 5 days 6 days 7 days
7.
* Yesterday, how many
hours did you watch TV or video movies away from school?
I didn’t watch TV
yesterday 1 hour 2 hours
3 hours 4 hours 5 hours 6 hours or more
8.
* Skipping meals such as
breakfast or lunch makes it hard for me to do well in my classes.
Yes, all of the time Yes, sometimes No
9.
* Yesterday, how many TV
shows did you watch?
1 show 2 shows 3 shows 4 shows More than 4 shows
10. * Do you currently take part in any other organized physical activities
or take lessons, such as martial arts,
dance, gymnastics, or tennis?
Yes No
11. Do you have a computer at home?
No, I do not have a
computer at home.
Yes, I have a computer at
home but I do not have internet
Yes, I have a computer
and internet at home
12. Do you encourage your friends and family to be
physically active?
Almost always or
always Sometimes Almost never or never
13. * Do you eat foods
and drink beverages that you see in advertisements?
|